Throughout biblical history, humans have interpreted suffering as divine punishment. It seems that God uses challenging situations to get people’s attention and call them back to a right relationship with Him. But at other times, suffering is a test from God to develop our faith and endurance. Here are some examples of trouble as punishment.
Job’s friends say that trouble is punishment from God (Job 20) so Job needs to repent and come back to God.
Israel is defeated at Ai because Achan disobeyed God by taking goods from Jericho (Joshua 7).
Jeremiah declares that drought, famine and war are punishment for Judah’s idolatry (Jeremiah 14:17–22; 16:5–18).
Later, Haggai says God is holding back the dew, rain and protection of crops as they build their own houses and leave the temple unfinished (Haggai 1:3-11).
Paul also suggests some are sick because they have neglected their fellow disciples in the church of God (1 Corinthians 11:29,30).
However, there are other times when suffering is seen as a test of character. Job’s suffering was a test from the devil despite his innocence (Job 1,2). James suggests that trials test our faith and develop endurance (James 1:3,4,12). Peter likewise writes that trials test whether our faith is genuine (1 Peter 1:6, 4:12).
So, how do we know when the suffering we face is punishment or testing? This is an issue I have wrestled with all my life. Personal sickness, family heartache, loss of resources—I ask why? Punishment or testing? The answers don’t always come quickly. Financial and personnel matters, conflict in the workplace—I ask why? Punishment or testing? These answers do not come easily either. Eventually, as I wrestle in prayer and discuss matters over with wise friends and colleagues, the answers do come. At times I wish there was a prophet or the Urim and Thummim to give a clear answer. However, I must rely on the voice of God’s Spirit through His Word, His people and my own mind for truth to be discovered (John 16:7–14). It is only being close with God that we can discover the answers, even if it does take time.